Skip to main content

Illusive Havens Part 3


Image may contain: one or more people and people sitting
Image 1: Gidan Bege Orphanage in Benue, Nigeria
Source: https://www.facebook.com/Gidanbegehomemakurdi/photos/pcb.260105698111607/260105628111614/?type=3&theater

Are orphanages the safe havens most people assume them to be?

According to Atu & et al., it may be the case that orphanages have higher disease prevalence rates for protozoan infections compared to the global averages calculated for resource poor countries (Minetti & et al., 2016, Atu & et al., 2016). As a whole, diarrheal diseases are the second leading causes of death in children under the age of five, beating out AIDS, malaria, and measles. Unfortunately, these statistics aren’t well known by the international community and consequently, malaria ends up at the forefront of public health initiatives.

 Children ages five and under are the most susceptible age demographic and when compounded with poor hygiene conditions and malnutrition, can lead to devastating results. The disease burden of diarrhea is incredibly high, killing an average of 2,195 children every single day and accounts for 1 of 9 child deaths globally (CDC, 2015).

 Across the four orphanages (Children of Mary Orphanage and Motherless Babies Home in Otukpo, Gidan Bege Orphanage Home in Makurdi, Mama Abayol Children’s Home in Makurdi, and Nongu u Kristu ui Serusha Tar (N.K.S.T) Orphanage Home in Mkar) sampled by Atu & et al., various socio-economic factors such as age, gender, and water sources were used as independent variables in the epidemiological survey (Atu & et al., 2016). All four orphanages were located in the Benue State of Nigeria, the same region highlighted in my previous blog post. If you’re curious about the transmission pathway of Giardia protozoans or about the ethnic conflict in Benue, refer back to Illusive Havens Part 2!

After obtaining the necessary consent from the children, the researchers analyzed prevalence rates of Cryptosporidium parvum and Giardia lamblia in stool samples. Of the 128 sampled children from the four orphanages, 43.8% tested positive for a protozoan infection. Prevalence rates were compared to the use of private wells vs. water tanks and it was observed that children using water tanks had the lowest prevalence rate (39.2%) compared to those that used private wells (52.4%) or boreholes (40%).




Image 3: An example of a water tank
It may be that the private wells used by the orphanages were not well protected and vulnerable to waste contamination. Children who “sometimes” practiced hand-washing yielded a prevalence rate of 36.5%, compared to those that did not utilize any hand-washing facilities (49.1%) after using the restroom. The inherent conditions of the four orphanages differed, from the availability of hand-washing facilities to their water sources. In addition, knowledge of hygiene practices differed between orphanages. Some children were practicing incorrect hand-washing techniques such as lathering insufficiently or even skipping the soap.

Figure 1: Table highlighting the relationship between the source of water and prevalence of protozoa in children’s fecal matter
Source: Atu & et al., 2016
Figure 2: Table highlighting the relationship between gender and disease prevalence.
Source: Atu & et al., 2016

The results definitely speak to the unbreakable link between socio-economic factors such as clean water/sanitation and disease prevalence rates. Additionally, these results underscore the conclusions drawn in the previous blogpost that children are the most susceptible individuals when it comes to water, sanitation, and health. However, I am not quite sure what to make of the difference in prevalence rates between male and female children. My best guess is that male children have a higher chance of exposure to contaminated water sources and food due to differences in daily activities. I believe that further investigation is required throughout different regions of sub-Saharan Africa to understand the disparities that arise in disease prevalence rates amongst different age groups, gender, and socioeconomic conditions. However, one thing is clear - orphanages are not immune to communicable diseases and may actually harbor conditions that exacerbate infection rates.


References:

Atu, B.O., & et al. (2016). Effects of Socio-Economic Factors and Hygiene Habits on Diarrhoeal Agents in Orphanages in Benue State, Nigeria. Nigerian Journal of Microbiology, Vol. 30 Issue 2, 3389 - 3394.

CDC. (2015). Global Diarrhea Burden. https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/global/diarrhea-burden.html.

Comments

  1. Richard taylorNovember 26, 2018 at 8:05 AM

    Another fascinating post that uncovers an issue not commonly reported.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Putting a Face on Childhood Diarrhea

The rotavirus is a highly-infectious double stranded RNA virus that serves as one of the most common causes of diarrheal disease in children . The two most common symptoms are severe watery diarrhea and vomiting, both symptoms lasting for 3 to 8 days . Subsequent dehydration of the body causes dryness in the mouth and throat, dizziness, and decreased urination. Infected individuals can transmit the virus through their feces and contract the virus by coming into contact with infected fecal matter; thus, addressing improper hygiene practices that lead to fecal contamination of water sources should be of greatest concern when it comes to rotavirus alleviation in sub-Saharan Africa. In particular, the link between water, sanitation, and health becomes strikingly apparent when examining how children come into contact with infected fecal matter. Unwashed hands contaminated with viral strains of the rotavirus, drinking tainted water sources, or consuming food prepared with unsafe water are ...
3 comments
Read more

Drinking Water and Typhoid

Image 1: Downtown Kampala Source: http://theconversation.com/why-kampala-holds-single-biggest-growth-opportuni ty-for-uganda-52230 In 2015, a typhoid outbreak broke loose in the city of Kampala, Uganda (Murphy, et al., 2017). The epicenter was Nakasero - downtown Kampala and the city’s most populated city district. The culprit was contaminated water. On February 6, a 42-year old man died of severe abdominal pain, jaundice, and a high fever. Initial testing of the ill man suggested typhoid and after a complete epidemiological survey in the epicenter of downtown Kampala, researchers were able to conclude that the mysterious disease was indeed serovar Typhi . Typhoid fever is a bacterial infection caused by Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi and most often transmitted by fecal matter. In most cases, contaminated water or food sources are the most common pathways of transmission. In the environmental survey conducted in Kampala following the outbreak, researchers gathered t...
4 comments
Read more

The Planeteer’s Introduction to Water and Sanitation

Have you ever wondered what water truly means to you? Thought about what it would mean if you didn't have access to water on a daily basis? How about clean drinking water? As a Californian   I’ve grown up in sunny California my whole life and as much as I love my so-called “golden” state, we’ve definitely had our fair share of water resource management problems. Water use and access in California are often subjects of great controversy and beget bitter sentiments from democrats, republicans, farmers, students, mothers, fathers, and the list goes on and on. As a Brit, you’ve probably seen the agricultural sector of California’s central and inland valley marred by water conservation efforts due to drought remediation interventions. Every time I drive on the Interstate-5 towards San Francisco, I see “Solve the Water Crisis” or “Is Growing Food Wasting Water” billboards littering the side of the highway. Even my family has suffered the costs of California’s water crisis. Ou...
4 comments
Read more